--Google Forms - SMS Alert

Get Notified of New Posts

Want a text when I post something new on I’m Just Saying?

The signup form opens in a new tab. Once you complete the form, close that tab to return here.

Already subscribed but want out? Unsubscribe here .

Democrats Won. Somebody Tell the Pundits

So, I just watched a YouTube video from a creator I usually respect, suggesting that Barack Obama could be the next Speaker of the House.

The logic? The Constitution doesn't explicitly require the Speaker to be a member of the House of Representatives.

In 2023, Donald Trump actually received three votes for Speaker. Well, one vote on each of three separate ballots, courtesy of Matt Gaetz (pronounced loser).

But the Constitution doesn't explicitly say the Speaker can't be a bunny rabbit or a duck-billed platypus, either.

And ooh, wouldn't it be cool if the Speaker were an actual wizard, Hogwarts robe, wand and all?


Perhaps the Founding Fathers simply didn't think it necessary to explicitly prohibit every ridiculous possibility future generations might dream up. And they certainly couldn't have anticipated a world where pundits, bloggers, bad-faith actors, and various, assorted, and sundry anonymous online entities could dress up fever dreams as supposedly serious political scenarios.

And yet, that snowball keeps rolling down the hill.

Here's the thing:

I got to vote for one (1) representative; in 2024, I also got to vote for one (1) senator. (Every member of the House runs every two years; roughly one-third of senators run every two years.)

That's how representative democracy works.

The representatives we elect choose their party leaders among themselves, by SECRET ballot when the election is contested. The House then elects its Speaker in a public vote.

Not political pundits, partisan provocateurs, professional pontificators, presidents past, or political prophets (self-appointed) who mistake their inflated opinions for constitutional authority.

Now that the elections are over, everybody seems to be up in arms about Democratic leadership.

Chuck Schumer should have done this.

Hakeem Jeffries should have done that.

We need new leadership!

Well, they must have gotten something right. Democrats just won majorities in both houses of Congress, which they'll take control of when the new Congress convenes in January.

I'm not suggesting that Schumer or Jeffries are beyond criticism. But shouldn't criticism have some relationship to actual results?

Had Democrats suffered a crushing defeat, the pundits would be demanding new leadership.

But Democrats won, and the pundits are demanding new leadership anyway.

So what, exactly, is the standard?

When the verdict is the same regardless of the election results, you're not evaluating leadership. You're just swapping scapegoats.

Apparently, winning an election is no longer enough to keep you from being declared a loser.

And just as I was about to publish this post, House Democrats made their choice.

They voted 251–11 to nominate Hakeem Jeffries for Speaker of the House.

Not unanimous, certainly, but hardly evidence of a party in open rebellion.

The full House won't formally elect its Speaker until January 3, 2027, when the newly elected Congress is scheduled to convene. But the Democratic caucus has made its preference unmistakably clear.

And when Jeffries wins that vote, he'll become the first Black Speaker of the House in American history.

Meanwhile, Chris Van Hollen has thrown his hat in the ring against Schumer for Senate leadership. That contest will be decided by Senate Democrats on December 1.

I've followed Van Hollen for more than twenty years, going back to his first congressional campaign. Every morning, I'd pass him at Oakland Mills and Guilford Road in Columbia, Maryland, religiously waving at passing cars with his campaign sign.

I was particularly impressed when he traveled to El Salvador to investigate the detention of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, one of his Maryland constituents.

If his fellow senators elevate him to leadership, I'd be elated. But by no means am I calling for Schumer's head on a silver platter.

And along with the pundits, political pretenders, and other self-appointed experts already mentioned, much of this cheering, jeering, and pot-stirring comes from Republicans eager to portray ordinary disagreements among Democrats as evidence of a party in disarray, conveniently distracting attention from their own record of congressional dysfunction.

But disagreement isn't dysfunction. Democrats can debate their leadership without being incapable of governing.

Republicans demonstrated what actual dysfunction looks like in 2023, when they needed fifteen ballots to elect Kevin McCarthy Speaker, then removed him nine months later.

That wasn't speculation. It happened.

For nearly two years, Republicans have controlled the White House and both houses of Congress. In fact, they still do. Their congressional majorities won't end until January, when the newly elected Democrats take their seats.

They've had nearly two years to govern.

Instead, they've chosen to follow Donald Trump blindly, even when they knew damn well that what he was saying didn't make sense.

Well, maybe foreign countries really will pay the tariffs.

And yeah, what this country really needs right now is a presidential ballroom.

They didn't have to believe any of it. They just had to pretend they did, because questioning Trump was apparently a greater political sin than insulting the intelligence of the American people.

And let's be clear: Even if Republican senators or congressmen privately disagreed with Trump, what difference did it make?


They didn't merely sit idly by as Trump threatened Armageddon, slapped tariffs on penguins on Heard and McDonald Islands, renamed globally recognized bodies of water, and repeatedly built monuments to himself. They defended him, excused him, and enabled him, handing him the matches as he frantically fueled the fiery furnace of hate and discontent, then, emulating Nero, fiddled ferociously while Rome burned.

Private disagreement means nothing when public obedience is all the voters ever see.

In the process, Republicans squandered whatever goodwill the voters had given them.

Now they're pointing fingers at Democrats, hoping everyone will overlook their own failures.

And the pundits are happy to help. After all, a supposed Democratic civil war makes better television than reporting what Congress actually does.

I'm not suggesting Democrats are incapable of dysfunction. But let's wait until they actually demonstrate it before declaring a crisis.

Perhaps political television could try something revolutionary: Report what Congress actually does instead of manufacturing another horse race.

As for Republicans pointing fingers at Democrats, there's an old saying:

For every finger you point at somebody else, three more are pointing right back at you.

I'm just saying.

Comments

--Blog Mobile Open Log

--Popular Posts (Built In)

Access Journalism Has Entered the Chat

‘I Don’t Even Know What That Means’: Theatrics Over Accountability

Make Up a Date, Make Up a Deal

Who Get's to Be an American?

Whistle While You Lie: The Subtle Art of Coded Speech

ICE Agents Are Wearing Masks — and the Public Should Be Alarmed

When Courage Ducks and Covers

We Dropped the Bomb, He Wore a Hat.

Regime Change

Healthcare Was Never the Enemy

-- More Posts